Big Picture View

Here is a summary of our big picture view of the markets. Note that our short-term views may differ from our big picture view.

Bond yields (long-term interest rates) reached a major low in June of 2003 and will trend higher until at least mid 2004. 

The US stock market will reach a major bottom (well below the October-2002 low) during 2004.

The Dollar commenced a bear market in July 2001 and will continue its decline during 2003 and 2004.

A bull market in gold stocks commenced in November 2000 and will continue during 2003 and 2004.

Commodity prices, as represented by the CRB Index, will rally during 2003 and 2004 with most of the upside occurring in 2004.

Copyright Reminder

The commentaries that appear at TSI may not be distributed, in full or in part, without our written permission. In particular, please note that the posting of extracts from TSI commentaries at other web sites or providing links to TSI commentaries at other web sites (for example, at discussion boards) without our written permission is prohibited.

We reserve the right to immediately terminate the subscription of any TSI subscriber who distributes the TSI commentaries without our written permission.

Interest Rates and Oil

We expect the Fed to hike short-term interest rates aggressively during 2004; not as part of a well thought-out plan or because Fed Chairman Alan Greenspan is not politically astute (he is most definitely a political animal), but rather because the bond market will force the Fed's hand. In a nut-shell, we think the Fed governors mean what they say when they talk about leaving the Fed Funds Rate near its current low levels for the foreseeable future and we are well aware that the Fed will not want to hike rates during the months leading up to the November-2004 Presidential election. However, once long-term interest rates begin to move sharply higher in response to growing inflation fears the Fed will have no choice other than to hike short-term rates with some urgency in order to rein-in the inflation fears. Not to do so, in such a situation, would invite a collapse in the value of the dollar and all dollar-denominated debt.

In other words, our forecast of a substantially higher Fed Funds Rate by this time next year is inextricably linked to our forecast of a large decline in bond prices (a large rise in long-term interest rates) over the next 6-12 months. In the absence of a large fall in long-term bond prices, though, the Fed will have the freedom to do whatever it wants with short-term rates. And Fed representatives have made it crystal clear that what they want is for short-term rates to remain near multi-decade lows over the coming year.

The upshot of the above is that if something happens to prevent long-term US interest rates from rising then the Fed will almost certainly NOT hike short-term rates. The question is; what could prevent long-term rates from rising or even cause them to fall?

As discussed in previous commentaries, the Fed could not prevent long-term rates from rising by directly intervening in the market (for example, by buying bonds). Such an action on the part of the Fed in an environment in which inflation fears were already rising would be counter-productive because it would heighten the inflation fears. 

In fact, the only forces that would appear to be capable of holding-down long-term US interest rates are forces over which the Fed has no direct control. 

Foreign central bank buying of US bonds is probably the most obvious and also the most benign (from a short-term US perspective) of these forces. In their efforts to prevent their currencies from appreciating against the US$ some foreign central banks have made enormous purchases of US bonds over the past year, thus helping to perpetuate the 'low-inflation illusion' and the low interest rate environment in the US.  However, while it is reasonable to assume that foreign central banks will continue to provide significant support to US bond prices during periods of US$ weakness it is doubtful that they could stem the tide in an environment in which inflation fears were rising at a rapid rate. In particular, the buying of US bonds by foreign central banks would likely be insufficient to prevent long-term US interest rates from rising if private investors, as a group, began to reduce their exposure to dollar-denominated debt (over the past year non-US private investors have increased their combined exposure to US debt securities, albeit at a slower rate than in previous years).

Foreign central banks are likely to play a part in supporting US bond prices over the coming year, but in isolation we don't think they represent a major threat to our forecast for a substantial rise in US interest rates. 

We think the biggest risk to our current interest rate forecast revolves around the relationship between oil and bonds discussed in the 24th November Weekly Update. Just to recap; in the aforementioned commentary we showed that the US T-Bond price has followed the oil price with remarkable consistency over the past 2 years, a relationship that makes some sense if we assume that the oil price has been driven primarily by geopolitics over this period. This suggests that an upheaval somewhere in the world that threatens to disrupt the oil supply has the potential to cause capital to come flooding into US Government debt. 

As well as giving a substantial boost to US bond prices an 'oil supply shock' would prompt a sharp sell-off in the US stock market and in non-energy commodities. Therefore, even if such a supply shock turned out to be short-lived it would effectively remove any pressure on the Fed to hike short-term interest rates. In other words, in such an environment Greenspan and Co. would be able to follow-through on their promise to leave the Fed Funds Rate at multi-decade lows for the next year, although we doubt that an oil-related crisis is something which is currently at the forefront of their minds.

By the way, an oil crisis would not necessarily originate in the Middle East. For example, a substantial portion of the oil imported by the US comes from Venezuela, so a problem in Venezuela could turn out to be the catalyst for such a crisis.

At this stage our forecast is for the oil price to experience a normal bull-market correction to the low-20s over the next several months so we are obviously not anticipating an oil crisis. However, we don't know what is going to happen in the future and if the situation starts to evolve in a way that does not mesh with our expectations then it will be important to revise our expectations. After all, we don't make forecasts for the sake of making forecasts. Our goal is to make money and any forecasts we make along the way are just roadmaps that are always subject to change as the facts change and/or as more evidence becomes available.  

Below is a weekly chart of oil futures. A weekly close above $32.50 in the nearest futures contract would warn us that an oil crisis might be brewing and prompt us to re-assess our interest rate forecasts. 

The US Stock Market

Stocks, bonds, and the liquidity cycle

Over the past 6 years the US stock market has been locked in a liquidity cycle. The cycle, which has occurred three times since 1998, goes something like this:

1. Stock prices decline and bond prices rally (interest rates fall)

2. The lower interest rates cause credit to expand at a faster pace

3. The increased rate of credit expansion creates liquidity in the financial markets and this liquidity eventually reverses the decline in stock prices

4. Stock prices start to rally and bond prices start to decline (interest rates begin to rise)

5. Rising long-term interest rates slow the rate of credit expansion and the level of liquidity begins to drop

6. Eventually, reduced liquidity takes its toll on the stock market and stock prices begin to decline

7. The bond market benefits from the stock market decline, causing credit to expand at a faster rate and so on.

Currently, we appear to be somewhere between step 5 and step 6 in the cycle.

This cycle can probably continue until the bond market stops benefiting from falling stock prices or until rising bond prices (falling long-term interest rates) are no longer able to stimulate faster credit growth. However, as long as this cycle does continue a major stock market bottom will not be possible. Rather, we will continue to get large declines in the stock market that end prematurely -- before valuations become low by historical standards -- followed by powerful rallies.

Our current stock market forecast is for a major low next year, but further to the above a major low will only be possible if the above-described cycle is broken. If not, there will still likely be a large decline, but rising bond prices and the resultant sea of liquidity created by the US financial establishment will cause another powerful stock-market rally to get underway before stocks have a chance of reaching the valuation levels normally seen near bear-market bottoms. 

Current Market Situation

At this stage there aren't many signs of weakness in the US stock market. Three of our bearish early warning signals were triggered during the week before last, but two of those signals were negated last week as a result of the NDX/Dow ratio moving back above its 70-day moving average and the NASDAQ Composite Index moving back into its upward-sloping channel. 

By the same token, the senior stock indices failed to make new highs during last week's rally and we are now entering a time of the year when important peaks have often occurred in the past. For example, major peaks in the Dow Industrials Index occurred on 18th January 1966, 2nd December 1968, 11th January 1973, 31st January 1994, and 14th January 2000. Also, a very important NASDAQ100 peak occurred on 6th December 2001.

Last week's failure to break-out to the upside opens up the possibility that the market has just completed a successful test of the early November peak and will now move sharply lower. If this is the case then the long-term support for the S&P500 Index that exists at around 960 (see chart below) could come into play within the next month.  

A quick drop to test support at 960 would become our favoured scenario if the S&P500 Index were unable to breakout to the upside during the coming week and, instead, moved back below 1050. However, by far the more likely scenario is that the market works its way higher to what will potentially be a very important peak during the first half of January.

We highlighted the Biotech Index (BTK) in last week's commentary and we'll look at it again now. 

In last week's commentary we mentioned that the BTK had pulled back, over the past 2 months, in what looked a lot more like a bullish consolidation than the early stages of a major decline. As the below chart shows, the consolidation is still in progress but any additional strength over the coming week would create an upside breakout. An upside breakout by the BTK would have short-term bullish implications for the overall market.

This week's important economic events
 

Click here to read the rest of today's commentary